Terry Cloth Polo Set vs Button Up Set: Which to Buy
By Mackweldon | Published: 2026-10-16
Category: Comparisons
Compare Mack Weldon's terry cloth polo and shorts set with the button up set on collar, color, and sizing so you can pick the right summer outfit.
Quick answer
Choose the Terry Cloth Polo + Shorts Set if you want a Johnny collar, a softer knit feel, and a relaxed but polished look. Choose the Terry Cloth Button Up + Shorts Set if you prefer a short sleeve button-up with a more open collar and a darker Night Sky color. Both are coordinated two-piece sets with separate top and bottom sizing.
The main difference: collar and closure
The polo set uses a Johnny collar, which has no buttons and a clean, rounded neckline. The button up set uses a short sleeve button-up with a full front placket. That single difference changes how the top reads: the polo looks more like a knit shirt you can wear straight from the beach, while the button-up looks more like a lightweight shirt you can leave open or button up.
Color and styling trade-offs
The polo set comes in Desert Spring and Bright White, both light and warm-weather friendly. The button up set comes in Night Sky, a darker color that hides spills and creases better but absorbs more heat in direct sun. If you want one set that works for a daytime cookout and an evening dinner, the darker button up set is the more forgiving choice. If you want the crispest look for a daytime event, Bright White is the cleanest option.
Sizing and fit
Both sets let you choose a separate size for the top and the shorts, which is the most useful feature if your top and bottom sizes don't match. The polo set offers sizes S–XXL for the polo, and the button up set is available in multiple size combinations for top and bottom. Terry cloth has some natural stretch and relaxes slightly with wear, so if you are between sizes and want a closer fit, size down on the top; if you want a looser, breezy fit, stay true to size.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Collar style: Polo set: Johnny collar, no buttons. Button up set: short sleeve button-up with a front placket. Pick the polo for a knit-shirt feel; pick the button up if you want to button or layer.
- Color range: Polo set comes in Desert Spring and Bright White. Button up set comes in Night Sky. Light colors stay cooler and look cleaner; the darker Night Sky hides marks better.
- Sizing flexibility: Both sets let you choose separate sizes for the top and shorts. If your top and bottom sizes differ, either set works; check the size chart for each piece.
Product facts
- Terry Cloth Polo + Shorts Set Desert Spring: Terry Cloth Polo + Shorts Set in Desert Spring includes a Johnny collar polo and matching shorts, both in terry cloth, with separate sizes for polo and shorts. The Johnny collar gives a buttonless, knit-shirt look, and separate sizing lets you dial in the fit for each piece.
- Terry Cloth Button Up + Shorts Set Night Sky: Terry Cloth Button Up + Shorts Set in Night Sky pairs a short sleeve button-up with matching shorts, available in multiple size combinations for top and bottom. The button-up front and darker color make this set slightly more versatile for evening or travel wear.
Which set is right for you?
Best for
- Anyone who wants a buttonless, relaxed top for warm days
- Shoppers who prefer light, warm-weather colors like Desert Spring or Bright White
- People who want a coordinated set with separate top and bottom sizing
Not for
- Shoppers who want a button-up front for a more shirt-like look
- Anyone who prefers a darker color that hides spills and creases
- People who want a single-size outfit without checking two size charts
