The two bundles share a build, not a color
Mack Weldon sells the 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer in two 3-packs that differ mainly by colorway. The All-Nighter bundle gives you three pairs of the signature boxer in the All-Nighter style, while the Medium Grey Heather bundle gives you three pairs in Medium Grey Heather. Both are sold as value bundles, and both let you choose a size for each of the three boxers, so you can mix sizes within one pack.
That per-pair sizing is the feature that matters most. If you have ever bought a multi-pack and found one pair fits differently from the others, this setup lets you build a set around your actual waist and preference rather than accepting three identical sizes. The color decision comes after that.
What each bundle actually contains
- 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers All-Nighter: 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers All-Nighter, sold as a value bundle with three pairs of the 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer in the All-Nighter style. Confirms you are buying three pairs of the same style, not a sampler of different fabrics.

3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers All-Nighter - 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers Medium Grey Heather: 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers Medium Grey Heather, sold as a bundle with three pairs of the 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer in Medium Grey Heather. Confirms the Heather Grey pack is the same boxer model in a different colorway.

3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers Medium Grey Heather
All-Nighter vs Medium Grey Heather at a glance
Both packs are 3-packs of the 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer with per-pair size selection. The catalog prices differ, and the colorways serve different wardrobe roles.
- All-Nighter 3-Pack: Catalog price USD 64.26, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 102.00. Three pairs in the All-Nighter style. Choose a size for each pair.
- Medium Grey Heather 3-Pack: Catalog price USD 73.44, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 102.00. Three pairs in Medium Grey Heather. Choose a size for each pair.
- Shared features: Both are 3-packs of the 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer, both are sold as bundles, and both allow a different size for each of the three pairs. Available sizes across the packs include S, M, L, XL, and XXL.
How to choose the color for your rotation
Color is the only meaningful difference the supplied information confirms, so treat it as a wardrobe question. Medium Grey Heather is a mid-tone neutral that sits quietly under light or dark trousers and reads as a classic underwear color. All-Nighter is the darker, more saturated option in this pair of bundles. If you wear lighter or thinner pants, a darker boxer is the safer choice against show-through; if you prefer a softer, more traditional look in the drawer, Heather Grey is the straightforward pick.
Neither color is inherently more practical. The better question is which one you will actually reach for on laundry day. If your drawer already leans dark, the All-Nighter pack adds three pairs that fit that pattern. If you want a visible change from your current rotation, Heather Grey does that without introducing a loud color.
Size combinations worth considering
The variant list shows packs such as S/S/S, S/S/M, S/M/L, and S/M/XL. That means you can build a pack around a single size or spread across two or three sizes.
- Same size throughout: Choose S/S/S, M/M/M, or another matching combination if you already know your 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxer size and want a simple replacement pack.
- One size up for one pair: A combination like S/S/M or S/M/M lets you test a neighboring size without committing the whole pack to it.
- Spread across three sizes: Packs such as S/M/L or S/M/XL are useful if you are between sizes or buying for more than one person, though the pack is still one bundle.
Price and value evidence
- 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers All-Nighter: Catalog price USD 64.26, with a catalog comparison price of USD 102.00 for the All-Nighter 3-pack. Shows the bundle is positioned as a value pack against the comparison price.
- 3-Pack 18-Hour Jersey Knit Boxers Medium Grey Heather: Catalog price USD 73.44, with a catalog comparison price of USD 102.00 for the Medium Grey Heather 3-pack. Lets you compare the two colorways on price as well as color.
What the supplied information does not settle
The records do not include fabric composition, care instructions, or fit notes beyond the available sizes. They also do not describe how the All-Nighter colorway differs from other dark Mack Weldon boxers, or whether the Heather Grey is a solid or marled knit. If those details matter to you, check the product page or the care label on the pair you receive rather than assuming.
The records also do not confirm thermal performance, moisture-wicking behavior, or any protective rating. The 18-Hour name and the All-Nighter style name are product names, not measured claims in the supplied information. Treat them as labels, not specifications.


